Moving business and organization information technology (IT) solutions “to the cloud” is a hot topic based on the articles, discussions and posts that I see.  After spending some time reading through several discussion threads on this topic, a number of recurring themes come through: There are many advocates who see it is the greatest thing in the world.   They go on to describe the efficiencies they have achieved and the thousands of dollars that have been saved on hardware and support costs.  Others share their fears regarding data security, protection from “prying eyes” and concerns with the potential acts of disgruntled employees.  Finally, there are the horror stories concerning poor technical support, “loss of service”, and the loss of mission critical data.

As I think about this, I can’t help but wonder what the average small to medium size business, organization or school would and should make of all of this.  Questions that I think they would ask include: What, exactly IS cloud computing?  Is it a good thing or a bad thing?  Is it something I should consider for my business or organization?  What is it going to do for me?   How do I sift through the alternatives and avoid the pitfalls?

To answer these and other related questions, I will be writing a series of posts over the next few weeks focused on cloud computing.  My goal is to put this topic in some perspective for small to medium size business, organizations and educational institutions that may be considering a “move to the cloud”.  This is the first post in the series.

What exactly is cloud computing?

Let’s start with a good definition provided by SEARCHCLOUDCOMPUTING.COM:

Cloud computing is a general term for anything that involves delivering hosted services over the Internet.  These services are broadly divided into three categories: Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS), Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS) and Software-as-a-Service (SaaS).  The name cloud computing was inspired by the cloud symbol that’s often used to represent the Internet in flowcharts and diagrams.

One element all cloud solutions have in common is some level of remote hosted services, i.e. services that are provided over the Internet.  These services will typically compliment services that are provided in house.  This is important to note.  Cloud computing isn’t an “all or nothing” proposition.  For most organizations and businesses, a combination of local and remote resources will likely make the most sense.  This mix can and should evolve over time as the needs of the organization change.

For this discussion, let’s focus on two elements of cloud computing: IaaS and the combination of PaaS and SaaS, which we will refer to under the broader umbrella of “Software Applications”.  For clarification, in this context software applications refer to standalone programs like Microsoft Word through much more complex applications such as a Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system or a shared software development platform that is accessed by multiple users. Read More→

Back in May, we reviewed two popular interactive whiteboard solutions offered by SMART Technologies and Mimio (now owned by Dymo).  As we said at the time, key considerations include:

  • The value of “finger touch” control that comes with a touch sensitive surface
  • The need (or not) for a portable solution, i.e. one that can be easily relocated
  • Budget constraints – How much do you have to spend per installation?

Since writing that post, I have been following another very compelling option that deserves consideration:  Polyvision’s eno line of interactive whiteboards.

Polyvision’s approach is unique.   (Warning . . . brace yourself for some “techy stuff!”) The Polyvision solution uses an active stylus that senses its position as it moves across the Polyvision ceramic on steel whiteboard.  How does it do this?  There is a passive “grid” buried in the whiteboard that the stylus senses.  The stylus then transmits the position information via a wireless Bluetooth connection to the host PC.   This is accomplished without any wiring or electrical connection from the whiteboard  to the PC or the projector (you still need the projector!).

How the Polyvision Eno Solution Stacks Up

Pluses

  • A robust whiteboard that looks like any standard dry erase board with the added benefit of  being magnetic.  The look and feel of the board goes a long way to eliminate the “be careful you don’t break it!” reaction I have seen from SMARTBoard users.
  • Lower purchase price and less expensive to install than the SMART Technologies boards since there are no electrical or other connections that have to be made to the board itself.
  • Available in versions that can be hard mounted, mobile mounted or that “snap” over existing chalk boards or whiteboards that have a steel backing or surface.
  • Supports two interactive users at a board at the same time (current model SMART Technologies boards have this capability).

Minuses

  • No “finger touch” control. This is only possible with an active touch sensitive surface (e.g. SMARTBoard).
  • A stylus that isn’t too bulky, but could be a bit of a challenge for younger users (about the same size as the Mimio or SMARTBoard styli).
  • If you lose or break the stylus, you’re “offline”  until you obtain a replacement (the same as Mimio).
  • More expensive and less portable than the Mimio solution.
  • Polyvision includes a choice of bundled third party software applications.  They are not focused on providing the level of user community support that is available from SMART Technologies or Mimio.

So Which is Better?

As is almost always the case, “that depends”.  Mimio continues to offer the lowest cost solution and an easy upgrade path for classrooms with an existing dry erase board.  It is also the most portable solution, if that is important to you.  For new installations or a classroom remodeling project, I now believe that Polyvision offers the more compelling solution.  The only “however” is this:  How important is it for your users to be able to tap into an established, active user community to help them get started?   SMART Technologies, Mimio and several other established interactive whiteboard suppliers have the advantage in this area.

Those are my thoughts.  What do you think?

Categories Classroom Tools, Education
Comments (0)

Cost reduction and technology management  was on the minds of those who attended a workshop held in Troy Michigan on October 26th hosted by Autumn Land Company.  Attendees included business managers from several parishes across the Archdiocese of Detroit.  The topics covered included energy sourcing alternatives, telecommunications options, teleconferencing and effective technology utilization.

As part of the event, Scott Simpson, Managing Principal of Vector Associates LLC, shared a presentation with the group covering the following topics:

  • Cost Reduction – Start with the Basics
  • Managing Existing Technology
  • Planning Technology Upgrades
  • Preparing for Future Technology

Although this presentation was targeted at a specific audience, there are a number of “takeaways” that apply to any business or organization:

Start by Asking the Right Questions
The first step in any successful cost reduction effort or technology implementation process is to gain a clear understanding of where you stand and where you are trying to go.  If your goal is cost reduction, start with a “deep dive” into your current financial details.  Key questions to answer include:

  1. “Where and how are we spending our dollars today?”
  2. “Are we getting competitive value?”
  3. “What could we do differently that can have a positive impact, both from an operations and a financial perspective?”

A key consideration is to not let “this is how we always have done it” or “we tried that once before and it didn’t work” stand in your way.

Effective Technology Management Today and Into the Future
Defining and implementing an effective technology strategy also begins with asking the right questions and through the application of several key concepts:

  1. Start from the end and work backwards – “What are we trying to accomplish?”
  2. View technology as a means not an end
  3. Look for the technology “pull” from users within your business or organization
  4. Tackle the process in manageable steps using a robust, flexible technology plan
  5. If you don’t have all of the answers, hire an advisor to help guide you

Learn more about cost reduction, effective technology management and how to implement a successful technology upgrade by downloading the full presentation.  Click here to access the file in pdf format.

What are your thoughts on effective cost reduction or technology implementation?

Categories Technology Mgmt
Comments (0)